In ENGL 110 (Workplace Communications), students chose a real job posting and prepared a résumé for that position. I had identifying details removed for peer review so classmates could focus their feedback on how the résumé addressed the posting.
Students revised the résumé and wrote a 300-word reflection on the feedback they used and what they would do differently in a future application. The first draft gave the reviewer something concrete to respond to. The second let the writer decide which advice fit the job.